Posted by Jordan Lee 🥉
24 days ago

Anyone know how do I choose the right yarn for knitting a scarf and which weight is best for beginners?

Honestly, I remember when I first picked up knitting again after all these years and finding the perfect yarn was such a chore. My granddaughter wants a cozy scarf for winter, so I'm looking for something soft but not too fuzzy that might irritate her skin. Any tips from you lovely folks on what weight works best for a simple pattern? I've got my eye on some acrylic blends on Amazon.

53

6 Answers

Sort by:
Frankie Suzuki avatar
Frankie Suzuki 🥉 240 rep
24 days ago
Top Answer

Oh, picking yarn for a scarf is one of those fun parts of knitting that can make all the difference, especially when it's for your granddaughter. For beginners, I'd go with a worsted weight yarn since it's thick enough to see your stitches clearly without being too bulky or fine, which makes simple patterns like garter stitch or ribbing come together quickly and look great. It knits up cozy for winter without needing advanced skills, and you can find plenty of soft options that aren't overly fuzzy to avoid any skin irritation.

Think about feeling the yarn in person if you can, maybe at a local craft store, to check how soft it is against your skin and ensure it's not scratchy, when choosing. Look at the label for fiber details, aiming for blends that feel smooth and have some give, which work well for scarves that need to drape nicely. Acrylic blends are a solid choice for their washability and affordability, just make sure the one you pick has a bit of wool or cotton mixed in for extra warmth without the itch.

A good tip is to knit a small swatch first with whatever yarn you're considering to see how it behaves in your pattern and how it feels after a quick wash. That way, you can adjust if needed before committing to the whole scarf, and it'll help you build confidence as a beginner too.

Roger Johnson avatar
Roger Johnson 🥉 143 rep
23 days ago

I've been knitting for years and scarves are my go-to project for gifting... For a beginner tackling a simple pattern and I'd suggest starting with a DK weight yarn; it's lighter than worsted but still forgiving, lets you see your stitches without squinting, and builds up a nice fabric that's warm yet not too heavy for a kid's scarf.

Look for something with a smooth texture to keep it gentle on sensitive skin, and avoid anything too fluffy that might shed or cause itching. Blends can be great for that balance of softness and durability. And hey, always check how it washes; you want it to hold up through winter wear and tear.

One thing that's helped me is winding a little ball and knitting a quick square to test the feel against my neck. Feels right? Go for it. Doesn't? Try another. Works great.

Malakai Torres avatar
22 days ago

When I teach knitting classes, I always tell beginners to opt for aran weight yarn for their first scarf; it's substantial enough to handle easily, creates a plush texture that's ideal for cold weather, and works wonderfully with straightforward patterns without overwhelming you.

Focus on fibers that are soft to the touch and low on the fuzz factor to prevent any skin issues, especially for a little one. Reading the care instructions on the label helps ensure it's practical for everyday use.

A quick tip is to rub the yarn on your inner arm to test for comfort before buying a bunch. That simple check has saved me from a few regrets over the years.

Chloe Wilson avatar
Chloe Wilson 9 rep
24 days ago

Start with a bulky weight yarn so you see quick progress and it's easier to handle for simple stitches. Choose a smooth and soft blend that's easy to wash and knit a small swatch to test feel and drape, and block it if needed.

Nathan Parker avatar
Nathan Parker 75 rep
23 days ago

For an easy first scarf go with worsted weight and a smooth and multi-plied yarn so the stitches are easy to see and fix. Smooth fibers are kinder on sensitive skin and they do not shed into the fabric. Avoid halo yarns like mohair or anything brushed if irritation is a worry which, yeah superwash wool blends and soft acrylic blends are comfy, warm, and machine washable, while cotton can feel a bit heavy and not as warm for winter. No halo.

Aim for needles around US 8 to 9, cast on to get a width near 6 to 8 inches, then knit a few inches and check the feel. Do a quick swatch and give it a rinse to see if it softens or gets scratchy. For length you will usually want 300 to 400 yards for a child and 400 to 500 for a teen or adult depending on width and stitch. Works great.

Gabriel Cruz avatar
Gabriel Cruz 80 rep
22 days ago

Worsted weight is the sweet spot for a first scarf because it grows at a nice pace and still shows stitch definition, though aran can be fine too if you want a slightly heavier feel. Pick a smooth, plied strand rather than a single that looks ropy since singles pill more and can feel grabby. I tried a fluffy alpaca once and it looked but every stitch fuzzed into the next and my scarf shed on everything.

If she has sensitive skin steer toward soft blends or superwash wool,, and if easy care matters choose something that can go in the washer. Mid tone or lighter colors make it easier to see your stitches while you work. Knit a palm-sized swatch with your planned needles and give it a quick wash then rub it against your neck or wrist to check for itch and drape.

Related Threads