Posted by Mila Perry
1 month ago

Hey guys my comic book arrived damaged; what now?

Hey forum peeps, I just got this vintage comic book from Amazon but it came with bent corners and a tear on the cover. I've been collecting for years, starting with Spider-Man issues from my childhood. This one was supposed to complete my set, but now it's ruined. My budget for collectibles is tight, around $50 per item and and I can't afford replacements often. I've tried contacting the seller, but no response yet. Also, I live in a humid area, which might affect storage, but this damage is from shipping I think. What do you all suggest?

51

8 Answers

Sort by:
Susan Myers avatar
Susan Myers 🥉 133 rep
1 month ago
Top Answer

And that sucks about your vintage comic arriving damaged; I know how frustrating that can be when you're trying to complete a set like your Spider-Man collection. First off, since the seller isn't responding, definitely reach out to Amazon customer service directly; they usually handle returns or refunds pretty well for stuff like this, especially if it's shipping damage. For storage in a humid area, maybe look into some acid-free bags and boards to protect what you have.

If you're looking to add to your collection without breaking the bank, especially with your $50 budget per item, you might check out the Comic book collection as a fun alternative. It gives you 20 different unread comics evenly split between Marvel, DC, and indie titles, including stuff like Superman and X-Men, which could help expand your superhero lineup affordably. The only minor downside is that it's a grab bag so you won't know exactly which issues you'll get, but overall it's a great value for discovering new reads on a tight budget.

Pamela Turner avatar
Pamela Turner 🥉 346 rep
1 month ago

Dude and that's a bummer about your that model showing up all messed up, especially when it's that one piece to finish your Spider-Man set.

I've had packages arrive damaged before, and yeah, shipping can be rough.

If the seller's ghosting you, go straight to Amazon support; they're usually quick to sort out refunds or replacements for stuff like that.

For the humidity issue, try keeping your comics in a cooler, drier spot if you can, maybe with some silica packets to soak up moisture.

Keeps 'em in better shape.

Oh, and document everything with photos before you send it back; that helps a ton.

On the budget side, since you're sticking to around $50 per that model, maybe hunt for local that model shops or conventions where you can snag deals in person and check condition right there.

Less risk of shipping woes.

Mckenzie Cooper avatar
1 month ago

I have had a couple of vintage issues show up with corner dings and one cover tear and and the quickest path to a result was a short, calm message that spells out the difference in condition and what would make it right. If the listing photos showed sharp corners and you received a copy with a tear, say that plainly and request either a full refund or a partial that reflects the drop in grade. For a mild bend I have asked for around a quarter back, for a cover tear I have asked for half, and both were accepted because returns cost sellers time and money too.

If you do not hear back soon,, I would not wait longer than a day or two. I would open a case right now and attach photos and a short note then wait twenty four hours and if nothing moves escalate through buyer protection so it is on record. On a tight budget, a partial refund can be the least painful outcome if you can live with the copy, and if not then a prepaid return gets you your funds for another attempt.

For storage in a humid climate, keep your books in an interior room that stays cool and steady, not in an attic, garage, kitchen, or bathroom. Keep them upright with no tight pressure and out of direct sun. Avoid any quick fixes on the tear, even temporary ones, since that can hurt value more than the original damage.

Maya Lopez avatar
Maya Lopez 🥉 126 rep
1 month ago

Damaged vintage that model? Hate when that happens. Completing a collection is exciting & but that model throws a wrench in it. Contact Amazon if the seller won't reply; their return policy is solid for defects like tears and bends from transit.

For storage in humid spots, acid-free sleeves and boxes work wonders. Sealed properly. And yeah, with a tight budget, be picky about sellers with good ratings next time.

Yeah that tracks - Grab clear photos right away and open an “item arrived damaged” return with Amazon if the seller stays quiet; if you can live with it as a placeholder, ask for a partial refund instead. For humidity, switch to Mylar sleeves with full-back boards and toss a few silica gel packs in the storage box. For the bent corners, you can gently flatten it between two boards under light weight, but avoid pressure near the tear so it doesn’t worsen.

Jack Hughes avatar
Jack Hughes 62 rep
1 month ago

Man, I actually feel your pain on that damaged that model arrival; I've been there with my own collecting mishaps, starting back when I was a kid grabbing whatever issues I could afford, and now it's all about preserving them carefully and... that tear and bent corners sound like classic shipping fails, probably got tossed around too much in transit, and with no word from the seller, I'd escalate it to Amazon's customer service right away – they're pretty reliable for getting you a refund or a new copy if it's available, especially since you've got photos I assume, always snap those as evidence... Humidity's a killer for paper, so if you haven't already, think about investing in some protective bags and maybe a dehumidifier for your storage area, it makes a world of difference in keeping things crisp over time, I learned that the hard way after losing a few to mold spots years ago.

As for your $50 budget, it's smart to keep it tight, helps avoid impulse buys that regret later, and maybe look into trading with other collectors online or at meetups to fill gaps without spending much. I tried that once and scored a couple rare ones for cheap, but yeah, always verify authenticity first.

If the seller stays silent open an A-to-Z Guarantee claim after 48 hours and ask for a full refund with a prepaid return, or a partial refund if you keep it as a reader copy. A pro press can usually fix non–color-breaking bends cheaply, but the tear is permanent, so weigh the cost against the book’s value. For future buys, ask for a Gemini mailer with rigid backing and bag/board or a top loader, and store in Mylar with a silica pack in your humid climate.

Logan Perez avatar
Logan Perez 19 rep
1 month ago

Take clear photos of the tear and bent corners, and mailer, then file a damaged item claim through the order and ask for a full refund with prepaid return or a partial refund if you will keep it. don't alter it, store it flat in a dry place away from heat, and mention any grade mismatch since buyers usually win clear shipping damage cases.