Posted by Dylan Diaz 🥉
1 month ago

Password managers vs memorizing everything

I've been using the same handful of passwords for years and which I know is bad. Thinking of switching to a manager but nervous about putting all my eggs in one basket. What's the practical upside and what should I watch out for?

43

6 Answers

Sort by:
Adam Price avatar
Adam Price 44 rep
1 month ago
Top Answer

Switching to a password manager is a smart move if you're reusing passwords, because it lets you generate and store unique, complex ones for every account without having to remember them all. The big upside is security.

With a manager, you can create passwords that are 20 characters long with random letters, numbers, and symbols, which makes them way harder to crack than something simple you memorize. Plus, most managers autofill your logins on websites and apps, saving you time and reducing the risk of typing errors that could expose you to keyloggers.

For example, I use Bitwarden, and it syncs across my phone and computer seamlessly, so I never get locked out. That said, you're right to be nervous about putting everything in one place, so pick a reputable one with strong encryption like AES-256. Watch out for your master password. Make it something super strong and unique, and enable two-factor authentication to add an extra layer of protection. Also, keep an eye on updates. Managers sometimes have vulnerabilities, so stay current with patches. If you're really paranoid, export your vault periodically as a backup, but store it encrypted on a separate drive. Overall, the convenience and security boost far outweigh the risks if you set it up properly.

Eleanor Cooper avatar
Eleanor Cooper 🥉 109 rep
1 month ago

I've been using a password manager for about three years without any major hiccups. The big practical upside is generating super strong, unique passwords for every site so you don't reuse the same weak ones everywhere. That means if one account gets compromised, the damage stops there. On the downside, if someone gets your master password, they could access everything, so protect that like your life depends on it. Pick a reputable one with good encryption, like Bitwarden or 1Password, and always use two-factor auth. Idk, this worked for me, and I sleep better knowing my stuff is secure.

The “all eggs” risk is real but you can mitigate it: choose a zero-knowledge manager, use a long passphrase you can remember, and add 2FA (ideally a hardware key) to your account. Disable automatic autofill or require click-to-fill so it won’t dump credentials into a spoofed page & and keep an offline recovery kit or encrypted backup in case you lose a device. If cloud sync still makes you nervous, a local-only manager trades some convenience for fewer online attack paths.

Jayden Mitchell avatar
Jayden Mitchell 🥉 132 rep
1 month ago

All these fancy password managers are just waiting to be the next big hack target. Stick to memorizing a solid base password and tweaking it per site if you're really worried. If you must switch, go for an open-source option you control locally to avoid cloud risks. Watch for any service with a history of breaches.

Mary Hughes avatar
Mary Hughes 🥉 114 rep
1 month ago

Ended up moving everything into a manager last year, idk, this worked for me. Upside is you get unique long passwords for every site, quick autofill, syncing across devices, and the app refuses to fill on look‑alike domains which helps against phishing. The basket risk is real, so pick a zero‑knowledge manager or a local file option, make a long passphrase you can actually type, turn on 2FA with an authenticator or hardware key, set short auto‑lock, and keep an encrypted backup of the vault. Biggest gotchas are losing the master or 2FA and locking yourself out, malware on your device grabbing access while you are logged in, and thinking autofill means you can stop checking URLs. If cloud makes you uneasy, use an offline vault format and sync the file yourself, or store a key file separately to add another factor.

Use the migration as a cleanup: rotate all reused passwords starting with email, financial, and any account that can reset others. Disable your browser’s built‑in password saver to avoid conflicts, and enable clipboard auto‑clear in the manager. Where supported, add passkeys or a second hardware key and stash backup codes offline so a lost device doesn’t lock you out.