Posted by Avery Garcia
23 days ago

How do I choose the right yarn for knitting a scarf?

I got this yarn from Amazon to make a scarf for my mom. But I'm new at knitting and not sure if it's the right kind. The label says it's acrylic but I heard wool is better for warmth. I tried starting the scarf, but the yarn keeps splitting. I have to finish it before winter. Maybe I need something softer. What should I look for next time?

37

5 Answers

Sort by:
Danielle Bell avatar
Danielle Bell 🥉 129 rep
22 days ago
Top Answer

For knitting a warm scarf as a beginner and opt for a soft acrylic yarn that provides wool-like warmth and reduces splitting. The Lion Brand Heartland yarn Great Smoky Mountains delivers 251 yards per skein in worsted weight, ensuring easy handling and machine washability. This actually choice stands out from basic acrylics due to its smoother, less prone-to-splitting texture.

Its softness and durability make it suitable for completing your mom's scarf before winter, while it may not match pure wool's insulation.

Lilah Gray avatar
Lilah Gray 95 rep
22 days ago

Hey and I've been knitting for years and totally get the frustration with yarn that splits, especially when you're starting out but then for a scarf, you want something that's warm but easy to work with, so think about yarns that are a mix of fibers, like acrylic with a bit of wool blended in, they give that cozy feel without the hassle so yeah... wool is great for warmth, yeah, but if you're dealing with splitting, go for a smoother texture next time, maybe a worsted weight that's not too fuzzy.

And for your mom's scarf, softness is key, right? Check the label for ply, higher ply means less splitting usually. Practice with a small swatch first to see how it knits up. You'll get it done before winter, no sweat. Works great.

Oh, and machine washable is a plus, makes life easier.

Dylan Diaz avatar
Dylan Diaz 🥉 155 rep
21 days ago

As someone who started knitting last year,, I had the same issue with acrylic yarn splitting all the time, drove me nuts and I almost gave up on my first project. For warmth, wool is awesome but it can be itchy or pricey, so maybe try a superwash wool that's treated to be softer and easier to care for. Look for yarns labeled as beginner-friendly, those are usually smoother and don't fray as much.

If you're in a hurry for winter,, pick something bulky to knit up faster, you know, bigger needles and all that. I switched to that and finished my scarf in a weekend but then I had to frog it once because of mistakes... yeah. Anyway, feel the yarn in person if you can, online pics don't always show the texture right.

Mika Zhao avatar
Mika Zhao 🥉 108 rep
22 days ago

Acrylic works for a warm scarf if it feels soft and you knit a bit denser and so pick firm multi-ply twists and skip fluffy halos in worsted weight.

If stitches seem loose or split, drop a needle size and try blunter tips, swatch the feel, and plan one to two skeins or a third for extra length with a wool blend as an easy warmer upgrade.

Ruby Kelly avatar
Ruby Kelly 34 rep
21 days ago

New knitter here who went through the same thing. Acrylic can be perfectly warm for a scarf if the fabric is dense enough and the yarn is soft on the neck. Splitting usually means the yarn is loosely spun or even a single but then for an easier time next round and choose a smooth worsted or aran weight with several visible plies and a firmer twist. That actually kind of yarn resists splitting and gives clean stitch definition and which is comforting when you are learning.

For maximum warmth with softness, wool is great, and merino is often the least scratchy. If you want easy care, look for superwash wool or a wool acrylic blend. Alpaca is very warm and drapey though it can shed a little. To help with the yarn you already have, try a slightly smaller needle and tips that are less pointy, work in good light, and let the ball dangle now and then if the strand seems to be untwisting. A gentle wash and block softens the fabric nicely. Works great.

Plan enough yarn by checking yardage and weight before you start. For a classic width scarf in worsted, two to three hundred grams is common, more if you want it long or use a textured stitch. Quick test before committing by rubbing the yarn against your neck to see if it feels comfy.

Related Threads