Posted by Jacob Murphy
1 month ago

How do you make new friends in a city where everyone already has a group?

I moved to a new city six months ago and my social circle is currently two baristas and a houseplant. I've tried a couple classes and a neighborhood meetup, but conversations drift off after hello. I'm free most weeknights, not a big drinker, and I'd prefer low-cost options. I'm looking for ways to meet people that don't require loud bars or selling my soul for pricey memberships. Any strategies for turning repeated sightings into actual friendships without being awkward? Bonus points for scripts that don't sound robotic.

36

8 Answers

Sort by:
Evan Hughes avatar
Evan Hughes 78 rep
1 month ago
Top Answer

The fastest way is to become a repeat face in low-noise, recurring spaces, then make one-step invites right after small talk. Pick two weekly anchors you can afford and repeat them at the same time, for example the library's Tuesday book club or language exchange, a Wednesday food bank packing shift, or the rec center's drop-in badminton hour. Show up early, learn two names each time, and ask one specific follow-up the next week so you are the familiar person, not a stranger. When you see someone twice, go name, callback, invite: "Hey, I'm Alex, we both did the 7 pm shift last week, how did that deadline go?" "I usually grab a cheap slice at Mario's after this, want to join for 20 minutes?" If money is tight and you do not want bars, stack free things that attract regulars like community garden workdays, neighborhood association meetings, park cleanups, or a run walk club that meets by the fountain at 6:30.

Turning it into contact info sounds awkward only if it is vague, so be concrete: "I walk the Greenway on Wednesdays at 6, want to swap numbers and I'll text before I head out next week?" After they say yes, send a same-night text with context and a plan, for example "Hey it's Alex from the food bank, Greenway walk next Wed at 6, meet at the north entrance by the big blue mural." For classes or meetups where chat dies after hello, bring one easy prompt and a small ask, like "What made you pick this class?" followed by "I'm grabbing a seat at the quiet cafe across the street to go over notes for 15 minutes, want to join?" If you keep missing, propose a tiny at-home thing that is low pressure and cheap, e.g., "I'm making soup on Sunday and doing a 45 minute puzzle, two people max, want to swing by at 5?" and put an end time so it feels safe. Track names in your notes app with one detail, then reference it next time, because remembering "you're the teacher training for the 10K" does more to build friendship than long conversations.

John Parker avatar
John Parker 19 rep
1 month ago

Quit chasing chemistry. Build predictable collisions. Pick two quiet, repeatable spots and times and become a regular. Same table at the library on Tuesdays 6 to 8 with a visible book or game on the table. Same park loop on Thursdays at 7 with headphones around your neck and not on your ears.

After you see the same faces twice, label the pattern and make a specific invite. Say, "I keep seeing you here on Tuesdays, I'm building a tiny weeknight co-work thing, low chat, high focus, 6 to 8, want to join next week?" Or, "I do a 15 minute decompress walk after this, want to join for one lap?" If they bite, ask, "What's the best way to reach you?" then text the plan that night. Follow up once if they ghost and then move on to the next familiar face.

Reese Reed avatar
Reese Reed 🥉 105 rep
1 month ago

People stick to groups because it is easy. Your job is to be the calendar, not the entertainer. Pick two recurring low-cost things and show up weekly for a month. Speak to one new person each time and end with a concrete plan inside 48 hours. Try, "I'm grabbing tea after this on Thursday at 7, join if you want and I'll be by the window."

Helen Cooper avatar
Helen Cooper 38 rep
1 month ago

Friendships take effort & so commit to showing up at the same places repeatedly. Join free community runs or walking groups if you're into that, or volunteer at local events where you work alongside people. Skip the scripts if they feel robotic. just ask open questions like what they do for fun in the city. Follow up with a text inviting them to a low-cost activity you both mentioned. It won't happen overnight, but persistence weeds out the flakes. That's how it works in reality.

Grant Cook avatar
Grant Cook 67 rep
1 month ago

I spent three months going to classes and leaving with no contacts. What finally worked was a weekly food pantry shift where I saw the same five people. By week four we got dumplings and two stuck as friends.

Rebecca Jones avatar
Rebecca Jones 🥉 207 rep
1 month ago

Moved to a new city last year and my brain goes haywire without some structure, so I started hitting up free library events like book clubs or workshops. They're low-key and repeat weekly, which helps me build routines without feeling scattered. Pick one that matches your interests, show up consistently, and chat about the topic at hand. Something like "Hey, I liked what you said about that chapter, what made you think of it?" works without sounding forced.

After a few times, I suggest grabbing coffee nearby if it's not a bar scene, but keep it casual. My quirky hack is setting phone reminders to follow up with texts like "That discussion on X was cool, any thoughts on Y?" It turns sightings into actual plans. Don't overthink it, consistency beats perfection every time.

Built a couple solid friends this way, and it keeps my ADHD in check by making social stuff part of a schedule. Avoid the one-off meetups that fizzle. go for ongoing groups. Seven months in, and I've got people to hike with now.

Co-sign on recurring groups but don’t ditch one-offs - use them to seed a recurring micro-plan: a simple “a few of us from tonight are grabbing a quiet coffee next Tuesday at 7, want in so yeah totally chill if not.” Volunteering weekly is another low-cost cheat code because shoulder-to-shoulder tasks make conversation easy; as you leave, try “I’m usually here Wednesdays - if you want a 20-minute debrief tea after sometime, I’m in.” Keep asks specific and time-boxed at first, then stretch them longer once there’s a little momentum.

Related Threads